Post Script – The Rosie Effect – Graeme Simsion

The Rosie Effect (Don Tillman #2)

The Rosie Effect

Graeme Simsion

The Text Publishing Company

ISBN: 9781922182104






GREETINGS. My name is Don Tillman. I am forty-one years old. I have been married to Rosie Jarman, world’s most perfect woman, for ten months and ten days.


Marriage added significant complexity to my life. When we relocated to New York City, Rosie brought three maximum-size suitcases. We abandoned the Standardised Meal System and agreed that sex should not be scheduled in advance.


Then Rosie told me we had ‘something to celebrate’, and I was faced with a challenge even greater than finding a partner.


I have attempted to follow traditional protocols and have sourced advice from all six of my friends, plus a therapist and the internet.


The result has been a web of deceit. I am now in danger of prosecution, deportation and professional disgrace.


And of losing Rosie forever.


My View:

You must read The Rosie Project before embarking on this novel otherwise nothing will make any sense. I am a fan of the original title – it was fun, quirky, poignant and unique, at the time, however I don’t think follow up is quite in the same league; it felt a little laboured, was a little too much “tell and not show” (though I must admit there were a few brilliant slap stick/ comedic visual moments) and the characters however didn’t have quite the same appeal as in the Rosie Project.


I found the character, Rosie, a little two dimensional in this narrative – maybe because mostly we did not hear her view point just a few negative comments or expletives. In this novel Rosie becomes more of the stereo type of the pregnant woman; needy, grumpy, tired… and in her relationship with Don she comes across as brash, sour (with a foul mouth), selfish…angry and shows little empathy or love for the unique individual that is Don Tillman, whom she accepted for his quirkiness in The Rosie Project – disappointing. The Rosie in this book did not equate with my perception of Rosie in the first novel. Don’s friends’ however were a little more interesting and engaging.


Overall a little laboured, a little too many contrived situations to illustrate Don’s “special needs” and not enough interaction between Rosie and Don. Maybe my expectations were a little too high – I did so enjoy the first book.





10 thoughts on “Post Script – The Rosie Effect – Graeme Simsion

  1. Oh, I am sorry to hear this one didn’t do it for you, Carol. It’s always so disappointing isn’t it when the second book doesn’t live up to the promise of the first. To be honest, The Rosie Project has been on my radar screen for some time. I still want to read that one. Then we’ll see about this one…or not.

  2. Was looking forward to hearing your take on this one Carol. Its definitely very different than the first novel. I really enjoyed the character development of Don and his friends – and those comedic moments, particularly the restaurant discussion – for me they were gold. Agree Rosie’s less endearing qualities are much more pronounced in this outing… but for me, personality wise she was never in the same league as Don, even in the original.

  3. This book is on my challenge list as well. I adored the first book so much, that I am expecting not to like this one as much. With that negative attitude of mine, maybe I’ll be pleasantly surprised.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.